Six Million Buyer Interactions Later, Consensus Has a Theory

This week we hosted a webinar with Rex Galbraith and Betty Mok (CRO and SVP of Marketing at Consensus) on the buyer who's quietly become the hardest one to sell to: the one who'd rather do anything than get on a call with your AE.

The data backs them up. Forrester says 75% of buyers now self-educate. Gartner pegs the time sales gets during an evaluation at 17%. Rex and Betty pulled from six million buyer interactions at Consensus to lay out what's actually working when most of the buying happens before you're in the room.

The Evolution of Buyer Behavior

B2B buyers increasingly prefer self-service over talking to reps. Forrester reports 75% of buyers now self-educate, and Gartner finds sales teams get just 17% of a buyer's time during evaluation. The old playbook doesn't work in this world.

"One of the monumental shifts that's happening in the marketplace is the way buyers buy. Buyers do not want to talk to you upfront," Galbraith said.

Transparency, content, and trust have to come before the sales conversation.

Four Ways to Engage the Antisocial Buyer

Drawing on data from over six million buyer interactions, Galbraith laid out four principles:

  1. Identify the Unfit Customer Profile (UCP): Most companies obsess over ICP. Galbraith argued that documenting your unfit customer profile prevents churn and wasted resources. "When we were bold enough to say no, we created this concept called an unfit customer profile, and we listed these are the people that we will say no to." The result: a 92% renewal rate.

  1. "Show, Don't Gate" Product Information: Mok pushed back on gated forms. "Gates don't drive people to give you their data; they block the antisocial buyer. These are audiences that want to make informed decisions, and they don't want to engage reps until they're ready." Buyers who access nine or more demos close at 55%, more than double the average.

  1. Demystify the Buying Group: Enterprise buying groups have tripled in size over the last three years, per Mok. Tailor messages for each decision-maker and influencer, and use tools like ZoomInfo and Apollo to map them.

  2. Deploy an Early Warning System: Consensus runs a "deal momentum" score that captures stakeholder engagement, meeting frequency, and content views to catch deals before they go sideways.

"When we deployed deal momentum scoring, we realized how much business we were missing. This gave us insight well before disaster struck, and our close rate went up significantly."

Transparency: The Currency of B2B Sales Success

Early demo access changes the dynamic of every sales call.

"Transparency is now the new currency. Give buyers access to information using clips, tours, and documentation. When they come to the call, it feels like a second call," Galbraith said.

Mok added a sharper point: "Competitors will access your ungated content anyway. Leading transparency allows you to set the record straight and educate the market first."

Personalization and Interactive Product Experiences

Mok's team uses AI to build interactive demos where buyers can skip sections, ask questions, or request summaries.

"When stakeholders tell you what they care about, you personalize their experience and let them set the agenda at scale. That's how you double conversion rates and accelerate deal cycles."

Personalized demo experiences make buyers 34% more likely to qualify as opportunities.

Transitioning from MQLs to PQLs

Buyers experiencing product value through demos convert at six times the rate of MQLs.

"The philosophy behind ungating is driving engagement, because engagement yields buyers. The more you show, the more they trust, and the better results you achieve," Mok said.

Key Takeaways:

  • Define Your UCP: Retain loyal customers by saying no to bad-fit prospects.

  • Ungate Content: Removing gates lifts engagement, trust, and close rates.

  • Demystify Stakeholders: Personalize messaging across larger buying groups.

  • Use Early Warning Systems: Deal momentum scoring catches problems before they kill deals.

  • Embrace Transparency: Open demos, content, and pricing earn trust and shape the narrative.

  • Prioritize PQLs: Hands-on product experience converts at higher rates than MQLs.

Modern B2B sales starts with rethinking the old playbook, embracing transparency, and meeting buyers where they are.

Learn more about Consensus at goconsensus.com.

Want to learn from more Revenue Creators? Join the RevGenius community and be part of the movement rewriting the GTM playbook.

Upcoming Events

Al Outbound Was a Mistake. We're Going to Say What Everyone's Thinking

AI outbound promised more pipeline. It delivered more noise. In this no-holds-barred panel, sales leaders get honest about what went wrong: why AI-generated outreach all sounds the same, why buyers are tuning out faster than ever, and what it actually costs when you stack tool on top of tool chasing a problem that technology alone cannot fix. More importantly, what smarter AI adoption looks like when the conversation stays human.

Demo Day

Experience the future of GTM with an exclusive look at the essential tech stack for 2026. This no-fluff showcase delivers high-value, 10-minute demos from brands solving real technical challenges, paired with lively community networking and exclusive partner discounts. It’s a straightforward, product-first event designed for immediate impact.
Headlining this month we have: Softr, Zoominfo, Reevo, Demostack, enso, Veles

Funding Announcements

GTM Hot Jobs from RevOps Pipeline

  • Head of GTM - Netswick - $84K - $96K - Apply

  • Growth Content Manager - Cresta -  $140K - $170K - Apply

  • Head of Client Success - Rapid Product Growth - $75K - $170K - Apply

  • Enterprise Account Executive - Outset AI - $160K - Apply

  • VP of Marketing - Read AI - $225K - $260K - Apply

  • GTM Strategy & Operations - Sierra - $180K - $220K - Apply

Are you hiring and want your job featured? Submit a role here.

Want to get your brand in front of 60,000+ revenue leaders?

Partner with us and put your name at the center of the conversation.

Keep Reading